Weekly album battle · No. 20 · Friday, 6 November 2026 · Final result

Standing on the Shoulder of Giants vs Mer de noms

Oasis against A Perfect Circle. Two alternative rock albums from 2000. Mer de noms won with 100% of 6 votes.

Mer de noms by A Perfect Circle, album coverWinner
100%
0 votes0%Standing on the Shoulder of Giants
Mer de noms100%6 votes

Mer de noms won with 100% of 6 votes.

How the vote swung (UTC)
Standing on the Shoulder of Giants aheadMer de noms ahead
Share card: Standing on the Shoulder of Giants against Mer de noms
Share the result

Mer de noms beat Standing on the Shoulder of Giants 100–0 in Riffology's weekly album battle

#RiffologyBattle #Oasis #APerfectCircle

Posting to Instagram? It doesn't show links, so post the picture with a caption.
Download image

The case for each

Standing on the Shoulder of Giants by Oasis

By 2000 Oasis had seen their label fold, swapped producers and lost two founding members, and Noel Gallagher had quit cocaine. Their fourth album sounds like a band taking its own formula apart. Noel traded his old gear for odd pedals and small amps, played nearly everything himself, and piled on drum loops, Mellotron, electric sitar and backwards guitars. Gas Panic! turns his panic attacks into Beatles-tinged trip hop, and Liam earns his first songwriting credit with Little James, a lullaby for his newborn son. Even the title is a Newton misquote spotted on a £2 coin and scrawled on a cigarette packet. It still went straight to number one in the UK, shifting over 310,000 copies in its first week.

Standing on the Shoulder of Giants is the fourth studio album by Oasis, released in the UK and Europe on 28 February 2000. It arrived after a testing year: Alan McGee had closed Creation Records, founding members Paul "Bonehead" Arthurs and Paul "Guigsy" McGuigan had left, and producer Owen Morris was replaced by Mark "Spike" Stent.

The full story, tracklist and credits →

Mer de noms by A Perfect Circle

Mer de noms came from the opposite direction. This was no famous band reinventing itself but a debut built on a friendship. Billy Howerdel, once a guitar tech for Tool and Nine Inch Nails, played his demos to Maynard James Keenan while lodging in the singer's North Hollywood home, and some of those ideas dated back to 1988. Where Oasis spread outward into psychedelia, this record turns inward. Its songs are named after people Keenan knew, with Paz Lenchantin's violin winding through brooding, heavy alternative rock. It entered the Billboard 200 at No. 4, then the highest debut for a rock band's first album, and all three singles reached the top 20 on two US rock charts.

Mer de Noms is the debut album by A Perfect Circle, the American rock supergroup, released on 23 May 2000 through Virgin. The title is French for "Sea of Names". It sits at the start of a run of studio albums that continues with Thirteenth Step in 2003, eMOTIVe in 2004 and Eat the Elephant in 2018.

The full story, tracklist and credits →

By the numbers

On paper: 3–2
Standing on the Shoulder of Giants
Mer de noms
28 February 2000
Released
23 May 2000
Helter Skelter
Label
Virgin
Oasis, Mark “Spike” Stent +2
Produced by
Billy Howerdel
Château de La Colle Noire, Olympic Studios +2
Recorded at
Perfect Circle Studios, The Chop Shop (Hollywood) +2
April–August 1999
Recorded
—
47:56 · 10 tracks
Running time
44:53 · 12 tracks
3
Singles
3
No. 1
UK chart peak
No. 55
No. 24
US Billboard 200 peak
No. 4
—
US certification
Platinum
2× Platinum
UK certification
Silver
3.8k
Listeners
8.3k
144k
Wikipedia readers, last year
85k

Charts and certifications from Wikipedia, credits from MusicBrainz and Wikidata, listeners from ListenBrainz. A dot marks the stronger number.

On Riffology

riffology.co →
Podcast · Episode 66 · 1 h 16 min
A Perfect Circle – Mer De Noms
0:00 / 1:16:25

Previous battles

Every battle →

Battle champions

Albums with the most battle wins.

  1. 1
    Mer de nomsA Perfect Circle
    1–0
  2. 21–0
  3. 3
    Rage Against the MachineRage Against the Machine
    1–0
  4. 41–0
  5. 5
    DoolittlePixies
    1–0
  6. 6
    BadmotorfingerSoundgarden
    1–0
  7. 71–0
  8. 81–0
  9. 91–0
  10. 10
    The Real ThingFaith No More
    1–0

How the weekly album battle works

Every Monday at midnight UTC the vault draws two well-known studio albums, close in popularity, era and style, and puts them head to head for the week. Everyone sees the same battle. You get one vote, and the result is shown once you've voted. Voting closes at midnight UTC on Sunday night, when the next battle starts and the result goes into the record books for good.

No album battles twice in the same year, and every finished battle keeps its own page, so the arguments can carry on.