Weekly album battle · No. 14 · Saturday, 31 October 2026 · Final result

Physical Graffiti vs Wish You Were Here

Led Zeppelin against Pink Floyd. Both released in 1975. Wish You Were Here won with 100% of 1 vote.

Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd, album coverWinner
100%
0 votes0%Physical Graffiti
Wish You Were Here100%1 vote

Wish You Were Here won with 100% of 1 vote.

Share card: Physical Graffiti against Wish You Were Here
Share the result

Wish You Were Here beat Physical Graffiti 100–0 in Riffology's weekly album battle

#RiffologyBattle #LedZeppelin #PinkFloyd

Posting to Instagram? It doesn't show links, so post the picture with a caption.
Download image

The case for each

Physical Graffiti by Led Zeppelin

Physical Graffiti is Led Zeppelin with the doors flung open. Eight new songs worked up at Headley Grange in early 1974 ran to nearly three sides of vinyl, so the band dug out seven unheard tracks from earlier sessions and made a double album of it. The range is startling: the Eastern sweep of "Kashmir", with John Paul Jones on Mellotron and arranging the strings and brass, sits beside the clavinet funk of "Trampled Under Foot", a country rock romp and a solo acoustic piece from Jimmy Page. John Bonham's cough even stays at the end of "In My Time of Dying", proof of a working band in a room together. It went straight in at number one in the UK, and it still sounds like a group at full stretch.

Physical Graffiti is Led Zeppelin's sixth studio album, a double set released on 24 February 1975. It was the first record to appear on their own label, Swan Song, on Atlantic. Eight new songs were recorded in early 1974 at Headley Grange, a Hampshire country house, where the band had room to improvise arrangements and experiment.

The full story, tracklist and credits →

Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd

Wish You Were Here is a different creature entirely: focused, haunted and built around absence. Pink Floyd spent months at EMI Studios in 1975 struggling for ideas after The Dark Side of the Moon, then found their centre in "Shine On You Crazy Diamond", a nine-part tribute to Syd Barrett wrapped around two pointed jabs at the music business. Barrett himself turned up, barely recognised, while they were mixing it. Critics were lukewarm at first, but time changed that, and three of the band have named it their favourite. Where Zeppelin sprawl, Floyd ache.

Wish You Were Here is Pink Floyd's ninth studio album, released on 12 September 1975 on Harvest. It followed The Dark Side of the Moon and was recorded over numerous sessions through 1975 at EMI Studios in London, using material the band had composed while performing in Europe.

The full story, tracklist and credits →

By the numbers

On paper: 1–3
Physical Graffiti
Wish You Were Here
24 February 1975
Released
12 September 1975
Atlantic
Label
Harvest
Jimmy Page
Produced by
Pink Floyd, David Gilmour
Headley Grange, Olympic Studios +2
Recorded at
Abbey Road Studios, EMI, London
*July 1970 *January–February 1971 *May 1972 *January–February 1974
Recorded
13 January – 28 July 1975
1:22:43 · 15 tracks
Running time
44:09 · 5 tracks
1
Singles
1
No. 1
UK chart peak
No. 1
No. 1
US Billboard 200 peak
No. 1
16× Platinum
US certification
7× Platinum
2× Platinum
UK certification
3× Platinum
12k
Listeners
17k
394k
Wikipedia readers, last year
675k

Charts and certifications from Wikipedia, credits from MusicBrainz and Wikidata, listeners from ListenBrainz. A dot marks the stronger number.

On Riffology

riffology.co →
Podcast · Episode 87 · 1 h 44 min
Led Zeppelin – Physical Graffiti
0:00 / 1:44:24
Podcast · Episode 76 · 1 h 41 min
Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here
0:00 / 1:40:37
Podcast · Episode 14 · 1 h 3 min
Pink Floyd – Dark Side of the Moon
0:00 / 1:03:06

Previous battles

Every battle →

Battle champions

Albums with the most battle wins.

  1. 1
    Mer de nomsA Perfect Circle
    1–0
  2. 21–0
  3. 3
    Rage Against the MachineRage Against the Machine
    1–0
  4. 41–0
  5. 5
    DoolittlePixies
    1–0
  6. 6
    BadmotorfingerSoundgarden
    1–0
  7. 71–0
  8. 81–0
  9. 91–0
  10. 10
    The Real ThingFaith No More
    1–0

How the weekly album battle works

Every Monday at midnight UTC the vault draws two well-known studio albums, close in popularity, era and style, and puts them head to head for the week. Everyone sees the same battle. You get one vote, and the result is shown once you've voted. Voting closes at midnight UTC on Sunday night, when the next battle starts and the result goes into the record books for good.

No album battles twice in the same year, and every finished battle keeps its own page, so the arguments can carry on.